Today's featured puzzle, whose constructor is unknown, was originally published on October 8, 1966; edited by Margaret Farrar; and litzed by Martin Herbach. This imaginative, forward-thinking crossword utilizes a trick I've never seen in any other puzzle, pre-Shortzian or Shortz era: the use of two unrelated themes, one based on grid entries and the other contained within the clues! The puzzle's main theme involves redefining music terms in wacky (and rather inconsistent) ways, much like the theme in last Friday's featured puzzle. My favorites of the six symmetrically arranged music-related clue/entry pairs are "Percussion accessories of poultry." for DRUMSTICKS, "Behavior that sounds like band leader's error." for MISCONDUCT, and "Musical symbol, sounds like two-family residence." for DOUBLE FLAT! BACK TO BACK ("Placement of two pianos.") falls flat for me, though, since the entry's connection to music seems rather dubious. Nevertheless, I enjoyed the grid entry theme, and I especially appreciate how the theme entries are both interlocking and, to some degree, stacked. The second, less obvious theme is completely bizarre: 20 of the 78 clues start with the words "Kind of"! The first five clues and entries, for example, are "Kind of ware." (STEM), "Kind of soon." (EFT), "Kind of curiosity." (MORBID), "Kind of paper." (NOTE), and "Kind of 'easter." (NOR). If incorporating a second theme isn't strange enough, the sixth clue, for URBANE, reads "Type of manner." (rather than the expected "Kind of manner."). Although the second theme is kind of cool, it at the same time feels a bit out of place to me since it draws away from the musical focus of the rest of the puzzle. Nevertheless, I always enjoy seeing a bit of creativity and variety in theme types and executions! The nonthematic fill in this puzzle is also nice, on the whole—HOBNOB, STAND PAT, MONGOOSE, TOOLKIT, and FOOTAGE in particular give it a nice bit of sparkle. On the flip side, the fill contains the six-letter partial FOR THE ("___ time being.") and feels a bit heavy on esoteric entries such as PHB ("Degree."), VAI ("Liberian people."), CUPELS ("Assaying receptacles."), MOBCAP ("Head covering, old style."), RHODORA ("Rose-flowered shrub."), and DESTRA ("___ mano [right hand]: Mus."), the latter of which could be considered semithematic. The nonthematic clues are mostly standard for their time period, though the THRACE clue ("Carved up region of SE Europe") seemed somewhat noteworthy. In all, this is a unique and fascinating pre-Shortzian puzzle! The answer grid (with highlighted theme entries) can be seen below:
In honor of Valentine's Day, here's an ennead of love-ly 1964 clues from my ever-growing list of Clue of the Week candidates. Most of the writers of these entertaining, thought-provoking, or downright ingenious clues are unknown.
- May 11, 1964 (litzed by C. G. Rishikesh)
- Clue: Where East and West meet.
- Answer: CARD TABLE
- September 2, 1964 (litzed by Mark Diehl)
- Clue: Parents' indoor sport.
- Answer: WAITING UP
- Clue: Smoke under fire.
- Answer: CIGARETTE
- September 8, 1964 (litzed by Mark Diehl)
- Clue: Items often stolen.
- Answer: BASES
- October 8, 1964 (litzed by Jeffrey Krasnick)
- Clue: Pre-TV living room fixture.
- Answer: PIANO
- October 11, 1964 (constructed by Jack Luzzatto, litzed by Jeffrey Krasnick)
- Clue: Symptoms of a mad, mad world
- Answer: DEMENTIAS
- Clue: He cometh no more.
- Answer: ICEMAN
- October 24, 1964 (litzed by Nancy Kavanaugh)
- Clue: Like the latest in bathing suits.
- Answer: TOPLESS
- December 14, 1964 (litzed by Mark Diehl)
- Clue: Man of the range.
- Answer: CHEF
|Image courtesy of the University of Hull.|